This may make some people pull their hair out, but I’d love to hear some arguments. I’ve had the impression that people really don’t like bash, not from here, but just from people I’ve worked with.
There was a task at work where we wanted something that’ll run on a regular basis, and doesn’t do anything complex aside from reading from the database and sending the output to some web API. Pretty common these days.
I can’t think of a simpler scripting language to use than bash. Here are my reasons:
- Reading from the environment is easy, and so is falling back to some value; just do
${VAR:-fallback}; no need to write another if-statement to check for nullity. Wanna check if a variable’s set to something expected?if [[ <test goes here> ]]; then <handle>; fi - Reading from arguments is also straightforward; instead of a
import os; os.args[1]in Python, you just do$1. - Sending a file via HTTP as part of an
application/x-www-form-urlencodedrequest is super easy withcurl. In most programming languages, you’d have to manually open the file, read them into bytes, before putting it into your request for the http library that you need to import.curlalready does all that. - Need to read from a
curlresponse and it’s JSON? Reach forjq. - Instead of having to set up a connection object/instance to your database, give
sqlite,psql,duckdbor whichever cli db client a connection string with your query and be on your way. - Shipping is… fairly easy? Especially if docker is common in your infrastructure. Pull
Ubuntuordebianoralpine, install your dependencies through the package manager, and you’re good to go. If you stay within Linux and don’t have to deal with differences in bash and core utilities between different OSes (looking at you macOS), and assuming you tried to not to do anything too crazy and bring in necessary dependencies in the form of calling them, it should be fairly portable.
Sure, there can be security vulnerability concerns, but you’d still have to deal with the same problems with your Pythons your Rubies etc.
For most bash gotchas, shellcheck does a great job at warning you about them, and telling how to address those gotchas.
There are probably a bunch of other considerations but I can’t think of them off the top of my head, but I’ve addressed a bunch before.
So what’s the dealeo? What am I missing that may not actually be addressable?
To be fair, you don’t always have to use the
[[syntax. I know I don’t, e.g. if I’m just looking for a command that returns 1 or 0, which happens quite a bit if you get to usegrep.That said,
man testis my friend.But I’ve also gotten so used to using it that I remember
-zand-nby heart :PIf you need to use bash a lot just to learn 2 “keywords”, then it’s not a good language.
I have looked at bash scripts in the past, and even written some (small amount). I had to look up
-zand-nevery time. I’ve written a lot more python than bash, that’s for sure. But even if I don’t write python for a year, when needed I can just write an entire python script without minimal doc lookups. I just need to search if the function I want is part ofsyd,osorpath.The first time I want to do an
else ifmy IDE will mark it red and I’ll writeeliffrom then on, same thing if I try to use{}.If a bash script requires at least one array and one if statement, I can write the entire thing in python faster than I can search how to do those 2 things in bash.
To each their own really. You have what you’re familiar with, and I have mine. That said, I’m not proposing Bash as a good language. It is by no means that.
Now, to use Python for comparison. With a year of not using it, I’d be asking lots of questions. How do I
mkdir? How do Imkdir -p? What aboutcpormvand their flags? Did I use to bring in some library to make this less painful?Cause look, I already use many of these commands in the terminal, basically all the time cause I work in it.
Fwiw, there’s a
bash-language-serverthat can warn you of some syntactical errors.