I try not to do bummer posts, but this was a good write up on the lobbying going on by rat poison companies against the efforts of animal rescues and environmental protection groups.
There are efforts going on in many cities/states/countries to ban these poisons that hurt more than just rodents. The effects are horrendous on the rodents and those who eat the poisoned rodents.
You might want to see what is being done where you live on the campaign against SGARs (second generation rodenticides) to push them to save your local wildlife.
I’ve seen so many photos and videos of raptors, foxes, weasels, eagles, and more that have lost their lives. The cruelty and ignorance needs to stop. I’ll spare you guys the pics, but this post is worth a read.
I want to address something pest companies have been bringing up a lot in an attempt to dissuade from a state prohibition on anticoagulant rodenticides. Namely, they really talk up the angle that anticoagulants have an “antidote” that can help cure exposed animals and people.
For the unfamiliar, anticoagulants work by inhibiting the production of Vitamin K in the body. Vitamin K helps our blood clot. Hence, anticoagulants stop blood from clotting. This is why many victims–from people to pets to wildlife-- die by internal bleeding issues (in their brains, in their guts, etc.).
So, both in human and animal medicine, patients are administered Vitamin K when they are suffering from anticoagulant poisoning.
Here’s the thing though that the pest companies conveniently leave out of the narrative:
Vitamin K can only be an effective treatment if the anticoagulant exposure the patient suffers from has been caught relatively early enough and dependent on how much ARs (and how many different compounds) have been in the person’s or animal’s system. Often, by the time an animal arrives at the hospital, the poisons have done too much damage to their bodies and has accumulated in such high levels that no amount of Vitamin K can reverse it.
Let’s be clear: people have DIED from these poisons too–also bleeding out–where the Vitamin K didn’t work.
Even in cases where Vitamin K has worked–it almost always requires multi-week if not multi- month daily doses. And usually the people or animals need blood or plasma transfusions-- sometimes numerous ones–because of all the blood loss they are suffering in the interim.
Remember the case of the Great Horned Owl family on Cape Cod in 2021 treated by New England Wildlife Centers–where nearly the ENTIRE FAMILY was obliterated by these poisons? Both parents and two babies died (one was bleeding out of every orifice and neither Vitamin K or an emergency transfusion with a resident owl could save him–see photo from NEWC). Another owlet did survive. But she required NINE MONTHS of daily Vitamin K doses until her blood would clot on its own again and she could be released.
And yet, pest companies and their lobbying associations disingenuously frame this antidote a one-time panacea–like a magical EpiPen or anti-venom where you inject the animal once and-- voila!–they are cured and any bodily damage they have incurred is immediately and completely reversed.
It’s bullshit.
Perhaps when these poisons were a rarity, and animals had modest levels in their systems, Vitamin K could help. But with these poisons so ubiquitous and so many compounds of them everywhere–it’s not as helpful.
Let’s also be clear that really, when a pet has been
poisoned by ANY rat poison–not just anticoagulants–early detection is the surest way to recovery. The beginning treatment is the same regardless of the type of poison. That is–induce vomiting, administer activated charcoal to absorb any remnants of the poison still in the digestive system, and then offer electrolytes and supplemental fluids for supportive care. The problem is, of course, many times we don’t know if an animal has been poisoned until this point has been passed.
I will concede the pest companies on one point though. ALL poisons are bad and none of them really should be in widespread or routine circulation. ALL poisons kill animals with first- hand exposure (which is more common than people think–we’ve all seen the photos and footage of broken open bait stations). And ALL poisons do work up the food chain or cause impacts in some secondary consumers at least to an extent, despite popular belief that some poisons do not.
Tufts Wildlife Clinic found the neurotoxin Bromethalin in the bodies of birds of prey and it was also implicated in the death of another Massachusetts Bald Eagle roughly around the same time of MK’s passing. It has also been found in the bodies of mountain lions.
Cholecalciferol, or as it’s more commonly known, Vitamin D–is often promoted as a poison that doesn’t cause secondary impacts. This is false. While there was one small and short-term study on barn owls fed Vit D-poisoned mice where the owls showed no impact, studies on other kinds of predators–like dogs–have shown secondary impact when fed mice or rats poisoned by Vit D. It’s even been theorized the rise in use of Vit D is contributing to coyote deaths (another canid with similar physiology as dogs) in California.
As someone with a science background, a lack of peer review research doesn’t mean something is safe. It just means it hasn’t been studied. And I have no desire to have our wildlife and pets be guinea pigs as we slot in one poison for another.
This is why Save Arlington Wildlife does not endorse or encourage the use of ANY rat poison and discourages their use overall. That is why businesses that sign our poison-free pledge and get to have SAW’s sign on their store windows have committed to no rat poisons.
We live in the woods, so we have mice, owls, and all sorts of other wildlife. I don’t want to hurt wildlife, but I’m definitely not going to tolerate families of mice in the attic. I also don’t have the time or energy to climb into the attic every day to check traps – so mouse bait it is.
My hope is that the mice are dying in or near the house, and not out in the open where an owl might nab them. I’ve found some indoors, and have smelled others. That’s good evidence to me that the house mice are staying in the house to die. I’ll look into MouseX like @just_ducky_in_NH@lemmy.world mentioned, though.
The SGARs that are the real problem are designed to kill in a single dose. The First Generation poisons take repeated feedings. That can be safer for the predators as it can have time to be metabolized, while SGARs can’t be, they just accumulate until the predator dies.
I’m just here to share info so you can make the right decisions for you. Some things we don’t know are problems until we learn more about them. The health of your family comes first, but if there is an equal solution that is also safe, I’m sure you’d want to have all your options.
I wish there was an easy compromise. I subscribe to an Owl community on Lemmy, so it’s safe to say I was already aware of the mouse poison problem when I decided on what to do. I’ve just been trying to reduce my guilt by telling myself the house mice are staying in the house when they croak.
It has also been on my list to stuff some copper wool into some spots where the mice might be getting in. If it’s not too hot today I’ll get on the ladder.
I believe (without much evidence) that the Barred owls visit our yard for frogs, toads, and voles. We live next to wetlands and have loads of toads.
Unfortunately according to Health Canada, while a single dose is lethal, it’s not lethal very quickly, and they can wander around for over a week before dying:
https://www.canada.ca/en/health-canada/services/consumer-product-safety/reports-publications/pesticides-pest-management/fact-sheets-other-resources/rodenticides-agricultural-settings/questions-answers.html
The first generation poisons also don’t work anymore, that’s why they invented the SGARs. They used to work in the 50’s, but rodent populations worldwide developed a resistance to it. Now they can eat warfarin until the bait is gone and survive.
Have you not tried
?
I have tried it wasnt very effective.
Why not?
Not really sure, they never went in. I tried it my barn and i should have at least caught one by accident since ive had them drown in partial filled watering buckets. I know it wasn’t a bait issue because i could fill sticky traps with same bait. It was something about the bucket trap itself. I washed it thinking it had something but nope.
I haven’t. What do people usually do with the bucketed mice? Drive them across the train tracks and release them?
Just some info here. No judgements, but there are things you may wish to consider when deciding what to do.
From Mouse Ranch
Thanks for the info.
Always a pleasure. 🦉
That is an option, yes.
Get a barn/attic cat?
That environment isn’t suitable for a domestic animal.
I think they mean a cat that grew up mousing and knows how to catch and eat mice. Both of my cats came from my in-laws farm, and both greatly enjoy when the first cold nights of late fall come around and a couple of mice make it into the house, because they spend the entire night chasing and ultimately killing the mice (and then we toss them outside for wildlife to eat because the cats are only after the hunt and prefer their kibble for feeding)