Maybe the wrong place to ask, so sorry to the mods if thats the case.

I’ve a load of movies on DVD and wonder if its worth converting to mp4 and building a personal media centre to save loading each and every disc. I’ve tried to convert a movie I like to mp4 today using VLC but that crashes. I then downloaded winxdvd ripper - that worked better but cut the movie off after 10 minutes (I fail to see why I should have to pay 40 quid to get more than 10 mins of video).

I also tried an old Ubuntu install on another laptop and Handbrake and VLC there but got no video at all.

Is there any app/program that is open source/actually free where I can just drop in my DVD and create an easy mp4 file to be viewed via my media player/TV?

Thanks in advance

  • GraniteM@lemmy.worldEnglish
    18·
    1 year ago

    I use a two-step process of MakeMKV to do the initial rip and then Handbrake to convert to a more reasonably sized video file. Maybe there are more efficient options, but this one works for me.

      • CmdrShepard@lemmy.oneEnglish
        5·
        1 year ago

        It rips the disks 1:1 into MKV format. Honestly, you could probably leave it there and skip the long Handbrake conversion. DVDs are only around 5GB of files.

        Also when installing MakeMKV be sure to Google for the free product key from the developers.

      • ChaoticNeutralCzech@feddit.deEnglish
        2·
        1 year ago

        Yes, it works with all protected discs I tried. It’s freeware and you only have to pay for Blu-ray support. A small issue is that it will never allow audio-only or subtitle-only MKVs, which would speed up the process of acquiring rare dubs & subs where HD video is available from elsewhere.

    • onebonestone@lemmy.worldEnglish
      2·
      1 year ago

      MakeMKV is the way to go. If you have enough space, just rip the streams as direct copy without re-encoding. This way you can encode later if needed with the best codec available at that time.

    • paultimate14@lemmy.worldEnglish
      1·
      1 year ago

      I’ve been doing exactly this the past couple of weeks.

      Also I’ve set up a JellyFin server to be able to access my backups. It takes so e tinkering with the folder structure and file names, but once I figured it out it does a pretty good job of scraping metadata. And it saves on the wear-and-tear on my optical drives only having to read each disc once.

  • ChaoticNeutralCzech@feddit.deEnglish
    3·
    1 year ago

    It is possible from a technical standpoint (look up libdvd or MakeMKV) but it might not be worth it for some titles. Here are some considerations:

    • ➖ Pressed DVDs, as opposed to DVD±R(W)s, last very long and do not take up too much physical space on spindles, in paper sleeves or organizers (depends on your apartment size of course). Drives do fail but can be acquired cheaply (or for free if you salvage them from old PCs and have a USB adapter).
    • ➕ DVDs will always have worse compatibility with modern equipment than MP4. Good luck getting a smart TV to play one from a drive over USB.
    • ➕ For content that only ever existed as SD video, your non-reencoded rip will be pretty much the highest quality available.
      • ➖ That rip will almost certainly be in SD MPEG-2, interlaced (unless it’s a movie), and gigabytes in size, usually a little over 4 or 7 GiB (most discs are single-layer or double-layer and the video bitrate is set to fill the capacity).
        • You can reduce file size to 10-25% by reencoding to H.264 or H.265, using a lot of computing power and losing a little quality. H.265 does not support interlacing and takes way longer to encode, but you can fit a good-looking 100-minute HD movie on a CD with it! Many pirates overestimate the bitrate they need with H.265, leading to unnecessarily giant release files.
    • ➖ Likely not a concern for you but ripping copy-protected DVDs could be illegal even for personal use while downloading others’ HD rips might not be, like in my country.
    • DVD subtitles are 1bit bitmaps, ugly and relatively big in terms of storage. Their positioning is tied to video resolution so they will be at the center left if muxed with HD video. The MKV container is the only modern one that handles them at all. Converting to SRT or other text-based formats requires OCR (which does not always fully work). If they aren’t on OpenSubtitles.org, I would rip them, skim the OCR and upload them there.
    • ➖ You will lose interactivity but that was usually more of a nuisance than a feature. I don’t think Bandersnatch or another similarly suitable title ever released on DVD. (Yes, I am confident that DVD Video is just barely capable of holding the entirety of that movie’s footage with full interactivity and everything but I doubt Netflix bothered, it would have cost a fortune.)

    I would definitely back up niche DVDs but not mainstream ones – depends on how much you trust the scene to have your back. Up to you, really.

    • Davel23@kbin.social
      2·
      1 year ago

      most discs are single-layer

      Many years ago I ripped a large number of DVDs, several hundred if not into the thousands, and the vast majority were dual-layer. Very few commercial movie releases were on single-layer disks, at least in the US. It sounds like you may be in another country so your experience may be different but where I am dual-layer disks were far more common.

    • ToeNailClippings@lemmy.worldOPEnglish
      1·
      1 year ago

      Thanks for the reply.

      From what little I understand UK law lets us have personal copies but nothing else. Certainly no distributing (and I wouldnt myself). This is just to make my life easier so I can find a film (or even TV show) easier and have it all in one place.

  • KISSmyOS@lemmy.worldEnglish
    3·
    1 year ago

    On Linux, you need the libdvdcss library in order to rip protected DVD’s with vlc.
    For legal reasons, it can’t be included by the distros directly but there’s usually a documented way to install it.

    On Ubuntu, this is:

    sudo apt install libdvd-pkg  
sudo dpkg-reconfigure libdvd-pkg
    • ToeNailClippings@lemmy.worldOPEnglish
      5·
      1 year ago

      sudo apt install libdvd-pkg
      sudo dpkg-reconfigure libdvd-pkg

      Oh right, cheers.

      Just tried that and managed to get an ISO image. So far so good, cheers!!