Right, they won’t care until they find out the instances moderation policy doesn’t fit for them and then they’re stuck with all their content on an instance they don’t want to be on anymore

Users aren’t going to care about server load. The only problem the users will care about is “Does this work right now the instant I want it to.”

Having an entire separate service/microservice that load balances instances wouldbe very complicated to implement for what is largely no reason. If an instance is at capacity, close registration or switch it to invite only and direct people to a different instance.

There’s also the option of doing something like the mastodon signup portal that just gives you a list of servers and a blurb about what they’re about.

Making a series of different instances that are intrinsically tied together and controlled by the same mod team already has a name: A centralized network.

Short answer: Yes.

Long answer: Yes, definitely.

is that it? should we just quit using these sites or what?

Yes.

I feel like if the OP wanted the post on Lemmy, they’d have posted it on Lemmy. There is no benefit to puppeting reddit posts for anyone involved.

I could listen to an hour of him telling me how terrible I am and I’d still love it

Waiting for 0.18.1 seems like the safe, smarter option to me